Every prospective chicken-keeper does the math at some point: "Am I actually saving money by raising chickens?" And every existing chicken-keeper has at least once looked at their feed bill and asked the same question with a hint of defensiveness in the voice.
The honest answer depends on what you're comparing against. If you compare backyard eggs to commodity supermarket eggs at $2-$4 per dozen, you'll never come out ahead. But that's not a fair comparison. Backyard eggs from hens that range outside, eat bugs and kitchen scraps, and lay rich orange yolks are pasture-raised eggs — and pasture-raised eggs at the grocery store cost $6-$11 per dozen depending on where you live.
Once you do the math against the right benchmark, the picture shifts.
I'll use 6 hens because that's roughly the floor at which keeping chickens makes practical sense for most families. Below that, infrastructure costs are too high per bird. Above 12 hens you start needing more serious coops and run space.
| Item | Typical cost |
|---|---|
| Coop (DIY or pre-built) | $200 – $1,200 |
| Run / fencing | $50 – $400 |
| Feeders, waterers, nest boxes | $60 – $150 |
| Initial bedding (straw, pine shavings) | $15 – $40 |
| Range total | $325 – $1,790 |
If you're handy and have scrap materials, you can be at the lower end. If you buy a pretty pre-built coop from a retailer, you'll be at the higher end.
Day-old chicks: $4-$8 each from a hatchery, or sometimes free from a neighbor. Started pullets (16-20 weeks old, ready to lay): $25-$40 each. For 6 birds, expect $24-$240 depending on which route you take.
| Item | Per year (6 hens) |
|---|---|
| Feed (~25 lbs/bird/month at $0.40-$0.60/lb) | $120 – $260 |
| Bedding refresh | $30 – $80 |
| Diatomaceous earth, occasional electrolytes | $15 – $40 |
| Replacement birds (2 per year average) | $50 – $80 |
| Total annual | $215 – $460 |
This is where most online "chicken math" articles overpromise. Here's the realistic version.
A young hen in her first year lays 250-280 eggs per year. By year 3 she's at 180-220. By year 5 she's at 100-150 if she's still alive.
For a flock of 6 hens at typical mixed ages, expect 1,200 to 1,500 eggs per year, or 100-125 dozen.
BUT — eggs aren't laid evenly across the year. Backyard hens slow way down in winter (short days = no laying), molt every fall (no laying for 4-8 weeks), and ramp back up in spring. Don't expect eggs every single day from every single hen.
If you'd otherwise be buying pasture-raised eggs at the grocery store, here's what you're saving:
| Region | Pasture-raised price/dozen | Annual cost (100 doz) |
|---|---|---|
| Hawaii | $11.00 | $1,100 |
| California | $9.50 | $950 |
| New York metro | $8.50 | $850 |
| Texas | $7.00 | $700 |
| Kansas / Iowa / Missouri | $5.99 | $599 |
| Mississippi | $5.25 | $525 |
Compare to your $215-$460 annual feed/bedding cost. In most places, you're saving $200-$650 per year on egg purchases — assuming you would have bought pasture-raised eggs.
The infrastructure cost amortizes over time. Build a $500 coop, save $400/year on eggs, and you've broken even in year two. After that, every year is in the black.
The honest answer: it depends on what you call "worth it."
The math above is averages. Yours will differ based on your local feed prices, your egg yield, your coop, your weather. The only way to know your actual number is to track it.
I built Henalytics specifically because I wanted my own number. It logs every feed purchase, every infrastructure cost, every egg laid, and every egg sold. At year-end it tells you your real cost-per-dozen and how much you saved versus buying at the store. The benchmark price is set automatically based on your state.
Henalytics computes your cost per dozen, total spent, and savings vs. buying pasture-raised eggs at the store — adjusted to your state.
Open Henalytics →The point isn't to validate or shame your hobby. The point is to know. And then you can make next year's decisions — bigger coop? Bigger flock? Drop the meat-bird batch? — with actual information instead of guessing.
🐔🥚